Select from the drop-down MENU & READ the Blog in your PREFERRED Language


Akbar & Harka Bai | Maharana Pratap | Mauryans | Razia Sultan | Miscellaneous | Jodha Akbar | FolkLore | Suggestions

5300+ comments registered on over 165 active posts, till now.
Plagiarism is a serious ethical offense amounting to copyright infringement. ZERO tolerance for Plagiarism.

Thursday, December 24, 2015

Why Maharana Pratap Chose to Resist Akbar || With comparison of Rajput & Mughal Accounts of "Divine Intervention" of Akbar in 1578

" A man does not live by bread alone. 
He lives by his self-respect too. " 

I am back with a new post that is a pre-cursor to the Battle of Haldighati series.

Sometime back, there was a debate on social media about the relative merits and demerits of Mughal Emperor Akbar and Mewar King MahaRana Pratap and who between them was the greater of the two. Articles of differing viewpoints were posted passionately. But they all missed the crucial point --> 

" Why there was a struggle between them"

After all, fighting persistently with a very powerful enemy over a long duration is not what anyone with a reasonable amount of sense would choose to do. 

The debate was centred around the notion of Greatness in relation to the two mighty contemporary personalities. 

{I had penned my views on the same in a blog post and had received some interesting responses. The link to this post is : What is the BASIS of GREATness?}

In this post, I am going to present my views on the possible reasons why MahaRana Pratap resisted the suzerainty of Mughal Emperor Akbar. Understanding the relations between the two and the reasons why the MahaRana continued his life-long struggle against Akbar in spite of acute hardships to his people and family, is essential to understanding why the Battle of Haldighati was fought and what its aftermath was.

The Battle of Haldighati was fought between the forces of Mughal Emperor Akbar and the Rajput King of Mewar MahaRana Pratap on 18th June, 1576. At present, 3 articles related to the famous battle have been posted on the blog, out of which the first one is part of the Battle of Haldighati Series. The links to the 3 articles are -

Calm Before the Storm - Efforts for Peace Between Akbar & Maharana Pratap | Prelude - Battle of Haldighati | Part-I

Rare Stone Inscription about the Battle of Haldighati Discovered near Udaipur this year
Chetak and Maharana Pratap | Eternal Legend ~ An Unforgettable Tale | With Pictures from Haldighati Museum

Background to This Post

I tried to delve into the "contemporary conditions" prevailing in the late 16th century in northern Hindustan in order to understand the reasons for MahaRana Pratap's opposition to Emperor Akbar. One thing which everyone would agree with - life could not have been a bed of roses for the MahaRana during his continual struggle against Akbar, who is often considered to be the most powerful Emperor on Earth during his times. 

The MahaRana's fierce resistance to Mughal suzerainty seems all the more incredible as his territory was surrounded by Mughals on all sides. In the south by Gujarat, in the North by the Mughal subas of Ajmer / Nagore, in the West by the other allies of Akbar, and in the East by the Mughal capital of Agra and other Mughal provinces.

While i was puzzling over this, i came across a research paper by the noted historian Dr. Dashratha Sharma, whose major area of interest was the history of Rajasthan. In his research paper, he presented strong reasons for MahaRana Pratap's aversion to the idea of submitting to Akbar and not wishing to become his vassal. Obviously, we all love our independence and so did the MahaRana. But this was not the only factor. The paper by Dr. Sharma raises some other pertinent points.

Among other reasons, Dr. Sharma mentioned how a Rajput noble was treated (read "punished") by Akbar. A little known fact about Akbar is that he was prone to lose his temper suddenly over small things. And there are many instances, such as the one covered in this post, when Rajput nobles suffered great humiliation due to his erratic mood swings.

This post explains the incident mentioned by Dr. Sharma in detail. This incident has been sourced from a contemporary Rajasthani chronicle written between 1571 and 1611, known as Dalapata Vilasa. The scans of Dr. Sharma's research paper, published in 1969, are included at the end of this post.  I have also tried to include some scans from this rare chronicle.

Those who have read old blog posts will relate to this incident, which occurred in 1578. In Mughal records, it is referred to as a "divine intervention" that affected Emperor Akbar. In other words, according to Mughal records, the Emperor was under a divine spell. But, the Rajasthani source gives a different interpretation of the same. Let's see what this is.

Contemporary Rajput Description of the "Divine Intervention" of 1578

Let's read the incident from the Dalapata Vilasa. The relevant scans are included at the appropriate places.

The following content is shocking and uses explicit words, which were used by Akbar during the episode when he was said to be under a divine spell by the Mughal chroniclers. No offence is meant towards any community and reader discretion is advised while reading about the incident.

Akbar traveled to Bhera, Punjab in 1578. There, animals for the hunt had been collected near Girjhak. Such a hunt is called 'Qamarga',  where the animals are collected in a big area & surrounded by troops from all sides. While Akbar went for deer hunting, the nobles played a game of 'kabaddi'. 

Upon returning from the hunt, the Emperor did not join the game but went to the tent of Sheikh Jamal. All the nobles dressed and went to pay their respects to Akbar. After some time, Akbar went to bathe in the river (the Jhelum). Akbar’s son, Salim, who was aged 9, was hesitant to enter the river. Akbar, therefore, dunked Salim in the river a few times. 

{Note : Recently, a TV series wrongly showed that Salim was sent away to the warfield in his childhood. Salim grew up in the Mughal capital and was never sent to exile.}

Image from Akbarnama {Copyright  : IS.2:56-1896 . } View of the hunt. 
It can be clearly seen that the animals are being hunted in a closed enclosure.

Now we come to the main incident. Rajput nobles were expected to pay their respects to the Emperor as soon as he arrived. Read the scans , whose translation is given below, to see what happened to a Rajput noble Dhanji when he arrived late in the Emperor's presence.

Scan mentions that the Rajput noble Dhanji got 4 to 5 lashes from Akbar's whip when he said that he could not report to court on time as he was dressing up. In this scan, the Rajasthani word "Paatisah Ji" is a corruption of the word "Badshah Ji" which means the "Emperor".

The Rajput noble, Dhanji, received four to five lashes from Akbar’s whip as he was "late" in paying his respects to the Emperor! Dhanji had explained that he had got late in dressing up. 

A young Rajput prince Prithidip, who was playing nearby with his advisers/attendants with the permission of his uncle, also received lashes from Akbar’s whip, possibly because he had not stopped play to offer obeisance to the Emperor. (See the scans below.)

The Emperor even ordered the killing of those advisers. 

Randhirot (Prithidip’s uncle) also received lashes on the orders of the Emperor, as it was found that he had detained Prithidip (from going to offer obeisance to Akbar). In fact, Randhirot had simply asked Prithidip to play on the side, as he was young, and his uncle did not think it was necessary for a child too to pay homage to Akbar. 

Upon being whipped, the Rajput noble Randhirot, unable to bear this insult to himself at the hands of the Emperor's servant, repeatedly stabbed himself in his stomach and killed himself before Akbar.

Instead of being shocked by the act, Akbar was further enraged seeing the 'audacity' of this Rajput, and ordered the dying Randhirot to be trampled to death by an elephant, saying - "Kill this b**t**d".!

The words as mentioned in the account are - "H*r**z**e ko maro".

However, it appears from the text that this order could not be carried out as the elephant was reluctant to move towards Randhirot. 

Scan mentions that the young prince Prithidip was playing with his advisers/attendants ; the young prince was also given 7 to 8 lashes by Akbar from his whip. Then, Akbar got his advisers killed for the "offence".

Scan mentions that Akbar called Prithidip's maternal uncle - Randhirot and asked him why he did not allow Prithidip to pay his respects to him (Akbar).

Scan mentions that Randhirot replied to Akbar - "My intention was not to stop him from paying his respects to you". Hearing the answer, Akbar ordered his servant to whip Randhirot. Unable to bear this insult, Randhirot - a self-respecting Rajput, then took his dagger and stabbed himself - once, twice, and then thrice, in front of Akbar,which further enraged Akbar who then ordered - "Kill the b*s***d (h*r**mz**a)". He called for an elephant to trample the dying Rajput.

At this juncture, the irritated Akbar went to the company of his wife (name of wife not given). The nobles also returned to their respective tents. Raja Man Singh of Amer arrived at the camp in the afternoon, after this incident, and went to pay his respects to the Emperor. (See the scan below for original text.)

After ordering the trampling of the Rajput, the irritated Akbar went to his tent. The nobles also returned to their respective tents. Raja Man Singh arrived at the camp in the afternoon and went to pay his respects to Akbar.

Akbar, who had cooled down by then, said to Raja Man Singh - "Did you see that b**t**d Rajput? He dared stab himself in front of me. Go and see if he is dead or alive. If he is alive, then look after him, and if dead, then cremate him". However, when Raja Man Singh saw him, the Rajput was in great pain and hanging between life and death. He died soon afterwards, despite the best attempts of Raja Man Singh and Madhav Singh (Man Singh's brother) to revive him. (See the scan below for original text.)

Here is an old blog article about Madho Singh (also called Madhav Singh) :
Madho Singh - Maharana Pratap - Akbar - Salim/Jahangir | Few Observations

Akbar asked Raja Man Singh to check on the Rajput. When Raja Man Singh and Madhav Singh went to see him, the Rajput was in great pain. Man Singh told his brother that they had to save him by any means.

Raja Man Singh, Madhav Singh and others went to see Akbar after the cremation of the Rajput. But Akbar was again found to be in a foul mood; and he was heard shouting as if he were not in his senses - "The Hindus should eat cows and the Muslims should eat pigs. And if they refuse to eat it, go and get a male sheep (ram lamb) and put it in a cooking pot. If it changes into a pig, give it to Muslims. And, if it changes into a cow, give it to Hindus. Surely, your "Devi" will do some magic." And he kept on rambling in this inexplicable mad manner. (See the scan below for original text.)

The Rajput died soon afterwards. Raja Man Singh, Madhav Singh and others went to see Akbar after his cremation. But Akbar was again found to be in a foul mood and rambling in an inexplicable manner.

He took off his turban and asked for a barber to shave his head. The panic-stricken barbers ran away in fear and Akbar started to trim his own hair with his sword!! Seeing this act of Akbar, which almost appeared to be madness, Shah Fatahullah Shirazi intervened and took the weapon from Akbar’s hand with the help of 2 other attendants. (See the scan below for original text.)

Akbar asked for a barber to shave his head. The panic-stricken barbers ran away in fear and Akbar started to trim his own hair with his sword. Shah Fatahullah Shirazi intervened and took away the weapon from Akbar’s hand. All the assembled nobles were then ordered to take off their turbans too. Akbar had his hair cropped.

Seeing the illogical behaviour of Akbar, Raja Man Singh asked the attendants of his colleague and friend, Prince Dalpit of Bikaner, to take him away from the place as soon as possible. He said - "The Emperor has gone mad, and you know what has already happened till now. I do not know what he will do or order next. You are the sole heir of your clan and quite young. For your safety, i request you to leave this place. I will manage the Emperor somehow." Despite the requests of Raja Man Singh, the prince refused to leave the place. (See the scan below for original text.)

Seeing the illogical behaviour of Akbar, Raja Man Singh asked the attendants of Prince Dalpit of Bikaner to take him away from the place as soon as possible. The prince refused to leave the place. Just then, Akbar again started shouting in an inexplicable manner. 

All the assembled Muslim and Rajput nobles were then ordered to take off their turbans. The Emperor then had his hair cropped. But he started shouting again, much to the surprise of those present. He praised the Rathores* and the Rajawats* of Rajputana but called the Shekhawats* mere Jats. He shouted this many times, much to the shock of the people present there. With great difficulty, Shah Fatahulla took Akbar to the sleeping quarters and stopped his rantings.


Rathores - They were Rajputs from Jodhpur.
Rajawats - Descendants of Raja Bhagwan Das of Amer. They were Kachwaha Rajputs.
Shekhawats - These Rajputs originally belonged to Amer. But, they formed a separate ruling family in 1471.

Next day, in the morning, the Rajput nobles prayed to their deities and waited. Akbar had his beard shaved and saying that he would invade Firang, (probably referring to the hills of Mewar, as the next campaign was here only) he permitted the nobles to leave their beards intact. 
(See the scan below for original text.)

Shah Fatahulla took Akbar to the sleeping quarters and stopped his rantings. Next day, Akbar had his beard shaved, while ordering the nobles to leave their beards intact.

Akbar then took off his turban and tore it into strips. Each Hindu chieftain was given a strip from the turban and had Gangajal (water from the holy Ganges) placed on his palm. Akbar announced - "All of you are required to preserve this water and the strip of my turban without fail, till we accomplish our campaign in Firang. I will ask these things from all of you when we reach Firang.(See the scan below for original text.)

Akbar tore his turban into strips and gave one strip each to every Hindu chieftain along with Gangajal. Akbar told them to keep these things safely till he asked for them back upon reaching Firang.

Such actions of Mughal Emperor Akbar have been strongly criticized by various scholars who have accused him of "believing in his Own Divinity" and forcing others to accept him as their Divine master. 

The animals which had been captured for the hunt were then released and Akbar rested for five days in his tent. On the sixth day, the Emperor had his beard shaved and all the nobles also had their beards shaved. The Emperor then proceeded towards Fatehpur Sikri,
stopping at various places on the way as mentioned in the scanMany days passed since that incident.

Akbar rested for five days. On the sixth day, he proceeded towards Fatehpur Sikri. 

En route, the party camped near Ramgarh after crossing the Chahnal river. Raja Bhagwan Das of Amer came to meet Akbar at the encampment. Akbar firmly admonished Raja Bhagwan Das, (and even his son Raja Man Singh) for abandoning the siege of Kumbhalgarh against Rana Pratap 

News came in the camp that the Mughal forces had sustained heavy losses and were on the run from Kumbhalgarh due to the ferocious onslaughts of MahaRana Pratap. Their supplies had finished due to continuous fighting with the forces of the MahaRana. Akbar was particularly angry because he had spent a lot of money on this campaign and yet the Mughals had faced defeat and had to run away from Kumbhalgarh (See the highlighted portion in the scan below; the words mentioned in the scan are in old Rajasthani - "Mari Chhadhi, Tuti, Ghano Bekhrak hui, Tuti Mari, Bhukha Mari, Khar Nisriya Huta").

When Raja Bhagwan Das came to meet Akbar at the encampment near Ramnagar, Akbar firmly admonished him and even his son Raja Man Singh for abandoning the siege of Kumbhalgarh against MahaRana Pratap of Mewar. 

Here ends the extract from the contemporary Rajputana text, which is in old Rajasthani language. This is an account by an eye witness, who was an ally of Akbar. A native Rajasthani would understand these scans easily. 

I have refrained from adding my own views here, but have simply described Emperor Akbar's behaviour, as recorded in the Rajput chronicle. As usual, readers are free to interpret it, and we can have the discussion in the comments.

A noteworthy point is : Akbarnama says - Mughal general Shahbaz Khan was suspicious of Raja Bhagwan Das and Raja Man Singh and did not approve of their presence during the siege against MahaRana Pratap. He suspected that Raja Bhagwan Das and Raja Man Singh 'secretly' held MahaRana Pratap in respectful terms.


Contemporary Mughal Description of the Divine Intervention of 1578

It is interesting to note that this incident of 1578 is also mentioned in the Akbarnama by Abu'l Fazl. But, he mentions this incident in glorious terms. This has been described as a stroke of madness or an epileptic fit by some historians, like Vincent Smith and Abraham Eraly, who opine that Akbar used to suffer from such spells. But, the same is called a "Divine Vision" over the Emperor by Abu'l Fazl and in the court histories of the Emperor's reign. Abu'l Fazl, Badayuni and Kandhari have considered this to be a DIVINE intervention

In Kandhari's words ->"A divine intervention had fallen on the emperor which hazed him."

Abu'l Fazl says --> "A sublime divinity took possession of his body."

Badayuni says --> "A strange state and frenzy fell upon the Emperor and the precedence was unaccounted for."

I have described this event from both Rajput and Mughal records because it is important to consider both versions here. Official Mughal records neither clearly describe any kind of madness nor do they record the degrading treatment given to that young Rajput chief and his maternal uncle just for the small "folly" of not paying his respects on time. But the actions of Akbar as mentioned in the Rajput records certainly appear strange. The Rajput record mentions the event clearly, without any decorative language, as present in the court histories of Mughal Emperor Akbar.



Dr. Dashrath Sharma's Research Paper

Finally, here is the research paper of Dr. Dashratha Sharma, where he has raised several points regarding Maharana Pratap's non-submission to Mughal Emperor Akbar. 

Dr. Dashratha Sharma, a well known figure in the field of history, served as the Director of the Rajasthan Oriental Research Institute in Jodhpur. He also served as the President at the Indian History Congress, Ancient History in 1967 and as the President of the Rajasthan History Congress, General History in 1969. He died in 1976.

Here is the paper.. 

Dr. Sharma has mentioned the degrading treatment given by Mughal Emperor Akbar to his Rajput noble. 

But, it is also true that some of his Rajput nobles were really 'powerful', holding considerable clout. The following are some examples :

1. In 1575, Raja Man Singh of Amer gave a "tight punch to Akbar" when the latter was hell bent on giving up his life in a moment of "madness". Raja Man Singh saved Akbar's life, though the latter was not in his senses and engaged in a fist fight with Raja Man Singh. Here is the link to this  little known but interesting historical anecdote : Akbar tries to fatally stab himself in his madness but Raja Man Singh Saves Him ; Followed by Angry Akbar Charging on Raja Man Singh . 

Here is an Akbarnama miniature showing the incident :

Here, Akbar's sword can be seen at some distance after it has been taken from Akbar's hands and thrown away by Man Singh. Akbar is angry and has thrown Man Singh to the ground. He is literally pressing Man Singh into the ground. All the courtiers are in shock, and appear to not know what to do. This is a scene from a drinking party where Akbar tries to injure himself with a sword in order to prove his valour at par with Rajputs and acts in a mad manner to almost kill himself by placing his sword on his chest and beginning to pierce it, but is saved by Man Singh.

Note that no one else could even dare 'touch' the Emperor, out of fear for his life and remained mute spectators. But Raja Man Singh went to the extent of fighting with Akbar to save his life. In the present post also, we saw Raja Man Singh confident enough of handling the 'madness' of Akbar, when he asked the young Rajput prince of Bikaner to leave the camp for his safety.

See the above-mentioned link for details

Here are the scans from Akbarnama. For more details, see the above link.

2. Raja Bhagwan Das of Amer refused to go into the fold of Din-e-Illahi when asked by the Emperor and said - "I would willingly believe that Hindus and Mussalmans have each a bad religion, but only tell us what this new sect of yours is, and what opinion they hold, so that I may believe in your sect." {Tarikh-i-Badouni, Low, Pg-323}


3. The same precept was followed by Raja Man Singh when he refused to attend the council called by Akbar, when the latter wanted Raja Man Singh to join his new order, Din-e-Illahi. 4 years later, Akbar again made an attempt to make Man Singh join his new order. Badayuni writes about this encounter of Akbar and Raja Man Singh in Tarikh-i-Badouni, Low, Pg-375,  as follows...

" His Majesty brought up the subject of " Discipleship ", and proceeded to test Raja Man Singh. 

But, Raja Man Singh said 'without any ceremony' :- " If your Discipleship means willingness to sacrifice one's life, I have already carried my life in my hand always for you : what need is there of further proof ? If, however, the term Discipleship has another meaning and refers to my Faith, I tell you i am certainly a Hindu. If you order me to do so, I will become a Mussalman, but I do not know the existence of any other religion than these two.."

4. We know that, just after marriage with Harka Bai, Akbar directly made her father, Raja Bharmal a mansabdar of 5000, which was the highest available mansabdari at that time. 

5. Akbar also got a Rajput princess of Amer married to another Rajput prince. He had adopted that princess of Amer as his own daughter and got her married as his own responsibility. Here is the link to that post, along with relevant scans from research papers and Rajput records which mention this : Akbar arranged marriage of a Princess of Amer with a Rajput Prince

Howeverwe need to keep in mind that such special position and authority was ONLY exercised by the Kachwaha Rajputs of the House of Amer during the reign of Akbar. I do not know what the exact reasons were, but it is true that Akbar was always close to the Rajputs from the House of Amer. 

In contrast, the relations of the Mughals with the Rajputs of Mewar were sour since the beginning. Babur and Rana Sanga were the grandfathers of Akbar and Maharana Pratap respectively. They fought the Battle of Khanua in 1527. The scars were not forgotten. The Mughal policies of empire expansion in the initial phase, which included forcible religious conversions, were not acceptable to Mewar. After winning the IInd battle of Panipat, the 80-year old father of Samrat Hemachandra/Hemu was captured along with many others and asked to embrace Islam, and, on refusal, he was beheaded. Although, Akbar was a child at this time, this conduct of the Mughal camp does have a bearing on the relations of Mughals with the Mewar Rajputs. 

Abu'l Fazl makes no mistake in proudly recording the details. This is from Akbarnama, Volume-2, Pg-71/72, English translation, ASB, which reads as follows --

" It came to His Majesty's ears that a slave of Sher Shah Suri - Haji Khan, who was distinguished for courage, prudence, and skill in collecting troops, was acting independently in Alwar, and also that the father and the wife of that ill-fated Hemu, and his goods and chattels were in that province. Nasir-ul-Mulk was appointed to that service along with a number of trusty and devoted followers. Haji Khan was frightened by the strength of the victorious army and fled before its arrival, and Alwar and the whole of province of Mewat came into the possession of the imperial servants.

From there they proceeded to Deoti, where was the residence and family of Hemu. The place was strong and there was much fighting, and a great resistance was offered by a handful of Rajputs. The father of Hemu was captured and brought alive before Nasir-ul-Mulk. The latter called upon him to change his religion. The old man answered, "for 80 years I have worshipped my God, according to my reli­gion. Why should I change it at this time, and why should I, merely from fear of my life, and without understanding it, come into the way of worship you desire?"

Pir Muhammed treated his words as if he heard them not, and answered him with the "tongue of the sword". After being victorious there, he came away with much plunder and 50 elephants and did homage at the Royal Court, and was the recipient of the royal favours of His Majesty

Badayuni tells us  - The wife of Hemu was able to escape the Mughal army, and went towards Bajwara in Punjab for shelter. More details can be seen below from his account Tarikh-i-Badauni, Vol-2, Pg-9/10.  "

Further, Akbar's policy of matrimonial alliances was not acceptable to the House of Mewar. Tension reached its peak when there was a proposal for a matrimonial alliance with the House of Mewar, which was refused by the Rajputs. This was followed by the brutal Siege of Chittor of 1567-68, ending in one of the most horrible massacres & shameful events in the history of mankind.

MahaRana Pratap's struggle was one against 'foreign' domination and, more importantly, a fight to maintain self-respect and independence from imperialism. It is famously said of the Rana that he bent his head only before his deity Eklingji and his parents. 

We have seen above that power is not everything. There is also "self-worth & self-respect". We have read the 'autocratic' treatment given by Mughal Emperor Akbar to the nobles, such as --

a. "Permission" even to let the beard remain intact.!
b. Orders to take off the turbans and get them shaved. {For some this is great dishonor.}
c. Preserving a strip from Akbar's turban along with Ganga Jal (water of Holy Ganges).
d. Getting admonished / whipped at any stage, subject to the mood, whims and fancies of the Emperor.

In the light of this whimsical and arrogant behaviour, Maharana Pratap's fight appears justified. He did not fight merely for his land but, more for the sake of ideals. He was very well aware of the legacy of his clan, both from the side of his father and his mother (a daughter of the Songara Chauhan clan), that he carried on his shoulders.  

In this struggle, he was completely & ably supported by the people of his kingdom and the tribals of the hills of Mewar. We rarely get to see such devotion where the people of a kingdom are ready to suffer along with their king rather than crossover to the "enemy" for "material gains" - a quality acknowledged in the Akbarnama also.!

I would like to hear the views of the readers. Do remember that it is important to evaluate historical events from a contemporary perspective and not with a modern insight. 

Thanks to Radhika for her inputs.
Article Category : Rajputs & Mughals(Akbar).

Share this article :

No comments:

Post a Comment